President Donald Trump’s 2020 reelection marketing campaign was powered by a cellphone app that allowed workers to watch the actions of his tens of millions of supporters, and provided intimate entry to their social networks.
Whereas the marketing campaign could also be winding down, the info technique may be very a lot alive, and the digital particulars the app collected might be put to a number of different makes use of — to fundraise for the president’s future political ventures, stoke Trump’s base, and even construct an viewers for a brand new media empire.
The app lets Trump’s workforce talk immediately with the two.8 million individuals who downloaded it — greater than another app in a U.S. presidential marketing campaign — and in the event that they gave permission, with their whole contact checklist as properly.
As soon as put in, it could actually monitor their conduct on the app and within the bodily world, push out headlines, sync with mass texting operations, promote MAGA merchandise, fundraise and log attendance on the president’s rallies, in line with the app’s privateness coverage and person interface.
But the enterprise software program firm that constructed a device to propel Trump’s mass motion is in monetary misery and has been sustained at key factors by the administration and the president’s marketing campaign, in line with interviews with former staff, monetary filings and courtroom paperwork.
Austin-based Phunware, whose inventory is buying and selling for pennies, just lately agreed to pay Uber $4.5 million as a part of a settlement over claims of fraudulent promoting and earlier this 12 months risked being delisted from the Nasdaq. In April, the corporate obtained a $2.9 million mortgage below the Coronavirus Help, Aid and Financial Safety Act because it was constructing the Trump marketing campaign app.
Marketing campaign watchdogs and former staff alike marvel at how a struggling startup recognized extra for constructing apps for hospitals and a Manhattan-based astrologer grew to become a juggernaut in Trump’s reelection bid, facilitating an ongoing information and fundraising effort that threw the corporate a monetary lifeline.
Even after main media shops referred to as the election for his Democratic opponent Joe Biden, the app stored pushing out content material supporting Trump’s bid.
“Everyone knows why Joe Biden is dashing to falsely pose because the winner, and why his media allies try so exhausting to assist him: they don’t need the reality to be uncovered,” learn a press release attributed to Trump posted earlier this month. “I cannot relaxation till the American Individuals have the sincere vote depend they deserve.”
On Tuesday, the app pushed out recent content material defending the marketing campaign’s vote-counting litigation in Georgia.
Final week, the app posted a fundraising attraction asking for donations to Trump’s newly shaped Election Protection Fund, which can ship many of the cash raised to a brand new political motion committee Trump shaped referred to as Save America. That PAC has few spending restrictions and will pay for lavish private bills or give cash to different candidates.
Whereas exercise on the app has slowed just lately, the enriched information it gathered on the president’s supporters — which may embrace every little thing from their contacts to their IP handle to their location information — can serve many functions going ahead, mentioned Adav Noti, a former Federal Election Fee lawyer who works for the nonpartisan Marketing campaign Authorized Middle.
Congress and the FEC haven’t set guidelines governing how campaigns can use individuals’s private information and or limits on the variety of entities to whom the marketing campaign can promote its checklist, he added.
“I’m assuming that what he’s going to do is switch the property of the marketing campaign,” Noti mentioned. “You may positively purchase the info and the marketing campaign can promote it to you, the trickier query is how a lot do you must pay for it.”
Phunware declined to reply to questions in regards to the app, the corporate’s monetary standing, its inside tradition and its relationship to the marketing campaign.
“Phunware has completely no function within the constitutional processes tied to US elections at any degree … and in addition has no function within the content material created or utilized by our prospects particular to our cellular software program or enterprise cloud platform for cellular,” CEO Alan Knitowski mentioned in an e mail.
A senior Trump marketing campaign official declined to reply questions on doable future makes use of for the wealthy supporter information the marketing campaign collected through digital platforms, together with the Phunware app.
“The information is owned by the marketing campaign and restricted no matter hit their servers,” mentioned the official who spoke on situation of anonymity to debate marketing campaign specifics.
As Phunware has hit difficult monetary occasions in recent times, it has shed staff, shoppers and buyers, 10 of whom agreed to talk with The Related Press, some on situation of anonymity as a result of they signed non-disclosure agreements or feared retaliation.
Phunware sued its shopper Uber in 2017, accusing the ride-sharing firm of failing to pay its invoices, in line with courtroom data.
However after Uber filed go well with towards Phunware, alleging the software program firm dedicated fraud by amongst different issues, permitting adverts for the ride-sharing app to point out up on porn websites, former staff mentioned the startup seemed for brand new methods to diversify its income stream.
Into the image stepped Karl Rove, former advisor and Republican strategist for President George W. Bush.
Lengthy earlier than reaching the White Home, Rove made his identify in Texas politics as a specialist in unsolicited mail, a type of political promoting he as soon as mentioned was efficient as a result of it was largely “immune from press protection,” or close to invisible to the general public.
In an interview with the AP, Rove mentioned a lobbyist who was pleasant along with his spouse launched him to Phunware executives, who instructed him the corporate had constructed apps for sports activities groups and Fortune 100 corporations that built-in geofencing expertise, which may monitor individuals’s actions by their cellphones.
Ex-Phunware staff and the lobbyist’s workers gave Rove a presentation, exhibiting off how the corporate might use cellphone information to ship out personalized political adverts that additionally have been exhausting to hint.
“His thoughts was blown. He was like ‘that is extraordinarily highly effective information,’” a former worker recalled.
Rove mentioned he brokered a relationship for Phunware with Trump’s 2016 marketing campaign digital director Brad Parscale.
“I assumed it had plenty of implications for politics so in a subsequent dialog I discussed it to Brad Parscale,” Rove mentioned. “He mentioned ‘fascinating’ and that was it, he by no means instructed me he had employed them.”
Knitowski mentioned in an e mail that he constructed the connection with the Trump marketing campaign.
“Phunware met the Trump Marketing campaign by me immediately after a 1:1 introduction from a Silicon Valley CEO who requested our consideration and participation in an RFP that additionally had Salesforce as a finalist,” Knitowski mentioned.
Stung by the Cambridge Analytica controversy — the corporate was accused of utilizing information improperly obtained from Facebook to foretell voter conduct within the 2016 election — and perceived bias from social media platforms, Parscale wished to bypass Massive Tech and reorient the reelection marketing campaign to attach immediately with supporters.
After Trump’s 2016 victory, Parscale labored with consultants and an ex-Cambridge Analytica information scientist to construct out a knowledge storehouse that would higher microtarget audiences with specialised adverts, former collaborators mentioned.
Phunware, in the meantime, began advertising its instruments to campaigns, saying it might attain doubtless voters by geofencing, by drawing digital boundaries round areas of curiosity “equivalent to occasion appearances, polling facilities, sporting occasions – even an opponent’s marketing campaign rally,” a weblog submit mentioned.
Two former staff mentioned Knitowski instructed engineers to embed invisible monitoring software program to observe customers’ conduct inside every app they constructed to spice up Phunware’s choices to campaigns.
“We have been instructed they wanted to be in each app to gather data for no matter we did, and the political vertical was a type of causes,” an ex-employee mentioned. “It will nonetheless go in even when the shopper mentioned they didn’t need it.”
Knitowski declined to touch upon the allegation. A former supervisor mentioned he labored to maintain the software program out of apps whose shoppers didn’t need it.
At month-to-month conferences, Knitowski would temporary workers on the startup’s prospects for getting purchased by one other firm or attracting angel buyers, one other former supervisor recalled.
The Republican Nationwide Committee, in flip, had employed a personal firm to construct a centralized hub for voter information for right-leaning campaigns referred to as Information Belief, and Parscale joined its board. All of the whereas, his workforce stored amassing cell phone numbers, and providing Trump supporters MAGA swag in trade for his or her digits.
“That is how Donald Trump stays president for 4 extra years,” Parscale mentioned, holding up his iPhone on stage at a 2018 rally supporting Texas Sen. Ted Cruz’s reelection. “Now this telephone is how we join with you. It’s how we flip you into the military of Trump.”
By early 2019, after Phunware had gone public, former colleagues mentioned Knitowski began speaking about his efforts to courtroom the Trump marketing campaign. In April, 15 p.c of the workers was laid off on account of “organizational restructuring and price reductions,” in line with a Securities and Alternate Fee submitting.
In July of that 12 months, Knitowski rang the bell on the Nasdaq. However by then income was dropping and main shoppers have been threatening to depart.
New York-based astrologer Susan Miller, whose glittery horoscope app had been one among Phunware’s most profitable, mentioned she would ask for options to be up to date, and nobody would name again.
“Have you ever ever talked to somebody at a celebration who’s all the time wanting on the door and never at you as a result of they need to speak to another person extra? It felt like that,” Miller mentioned. “They simply handled me like an previous shoe.”
An investor mentioned Knitowski stopped returning his calls, too.
“The man appears very shady. He’s all of your greatest good friend when he’s seeking to increase cash and after you have questions he’s nowhere to be seen,” mentioned Scott Walker, who mentioned he misplaced greater than $200,000 after Phunware’s inventory tanked.
In August, there was one thing new to announce: work with American Made Media Consultants, “in any other case often called the ‘Trump-Pence 2020’ and ‘Hold America Nice’ Marketing campaign,” Knitowski mentioned in an earnings name.
In accordance with a doc filed with Federal Communications Fee two months later, the corporate’s administrators included marketing campaign operations director Sean Dollman and marketing campaign counsel Alex Cannon.
Phunware would later reveal extra particulars about its work on the Trump app, which would come with location-based instruments and different options to assist the marketing campaign crowdsource new customers. Plus, there could be a gamified loyalty system, the place supporters might accumulate factors to spend on signed MAGA hats or pose for an image with Trump.
By September 2019, 18 p.c of the remaining workers was laid off after shopper Fox Networks Group left, taking a big share of Phunware’s gross sales with them, in line with filings.
Managers requested engineers in Phunware’s Newport Seashore workplace in the event that they wished to work on the Trump app, and a few engineers who have been opposed resigned, a former worker mentioned.
Then in April, as coronavirus instances surged and stay-at-home orders shut down enterprise, Phunware acquired a $2.9 million mortgage from the U.S. Small Enterprise Administration’s Paycheck Safety Program, a aid fund that Congress created to assist small companies hold staff employed by the pandemic.
Phunware COO Randall Crowder denied political favoritism helped Phunware get the mortgage.
“We obtained no assist from the Trump marketing campaign — boy I want we might have, what an effective way to have mates in excessive locations — however that didn’t have any implication on what we did,” Crowder mentioned in a recorded interview.
Phunware declined to return the cash after the administration demanded that public corporations that acquired greater than $2 million give it again.
The following month, Nasdaq notified the corporate it could possibly be delisted over its funds. To remain listed, corporations should meet a set of requirements to reassure buyers that because the preliminary public providing, they continue to be a reputable firm.
SEC data revealed that by July, American Made Media Consultants accounted for one-third of Phunware’s gross sales, paying Phunware greater than $1.6 million within the first half of the 12 months. The Marketing campaign Authorized Middle filed an FEC criticism alleging that the Trump marketing campaign and a significant PAC supporting it had shielded their spending on Phunware and different subcontractors by American Made Media Consultants.
Because the pandemic stored many supporters at house, Trump’s marketing campaign used the app to accumulate new customers remotely, and Parscale touted how the app was retooled to assist digital occasions. In accordance with on-line information supplier Apptopia, practically 860,000 individuals downloaded the Trump app in July, the identical month Biden’s marketing campaign deserted its first app, Workforce Joe, and requested followers to obtain a completely new app, Vote Joe (solely 11,075 did).
By mid-November, 2.8 million individuals had downloaded the Trump app, which Apptopia CEO Eliran Sapir estimated might give the marketing campaign tons of of tens of millions of telephone numbers, enabling it to succeed in individuals whose numbers have been saved of their mates’ contact lists however by no means consented to being contacted. A Carnegie Mellon College researcher, nevertheless, estimated the full could be nearer to 27 million on account of duplicate telephone numbers.
By then, the app had already laid the groundwork for a coordinated ultimate months, permitting marketing campaign officers to mannequin supporters’ conduct below quarantine and incentivize them to look at rallies.
“Why is that app so invaluable? As a result of individuals like sharing messages with their mates from the marketing campaign and getting information and updates,” mentioned Republican advisor Eric Wilson. “Nevertheless it’s not simply an extractive useful resource. It’s additionally producing contacts and mindshare on behalf of the marketing campaign.”
Phunware’s monetary troubles hadn’t abated, nevertheless.
In a Thursday SEC submitting, Phunware abruptly stopped disclosing its high prospects by identify. However by matching the accounting figures to previous filings, AP derived that American Made Media Consultants is Phunware’s single greatest buyer, and paid Phunware $2.4 million over the primary 9 months of this 12 months, accounting for practically one-third of Phunware’s income. Two former staff concurred. The app developer additionally disclosed sizable debt and expressed “substantial doubt about its capability to proceed as a going concern.”
On an earnings name with analysts final week, the corporate by no means talked about its work for the Trump marketing campaign, as a substitute specializing in its future progress potential. Regardless of the corporate’s uncertainties, some analysts say it has a optimistic long-term outlook because of the progress in cellular utilization.
Final month, its inventory rose barely after the corporate introduced it had completed two contracts for Honeywell. Honeywell fired again on Twitter, saying it had requested Phunware to retract its launch, and that the commercial conglomerate “doesn’t have an ongoing relationship with Phunware and doesn’t plan to work with Phunware sooner or later.”
A second firm, Hewlett Packard Enterprise, instructed AP Phunware had publicized a partnership between the businesses the place none existed. Knitowski declined to touch upon both occasion.
“We by no means had a relationship with Phunware, we don’t have any formalized partnership with them,” mentioned spokesman Adam Bauer. “We didn’t authorize them to problem that press launch and we requested them to take it down.”
Extra must-read tech coverage from Fortune:
- Hackers try to disrupt and steal COVID-19 vaccine research
- Right here’s how President-elect Biden plans to tackle online abuse
- What’s in a reputation? For Tesla’s Full Self Driving, it might be hazard
- What my day on conservative social network Parler was like
- He’s frightened A.I. may destroy humanity. Simply don’t confuse him with Elon Musk